Car Yearsto Avoid

2019 Toyota Highlander Problems

What owners have reported about the 2019 Toyota Highlander: which problems and issues come up most, at what mileage, and which recalls to check.

From NHTSA owner complaints and recalls. Updated Nov 16, 2026.

Is the 2019 Toyota Highlander a good year?

It's one of the worst years for the Highlander. Owners have filed 517 complaints with NHTSA, the 4th most of 25 Highlander model years. The most reported problems involve the transmission, fuel system and engine. Transmission complaints most often came at about 15,000–93,000 miles.

517 complaints 3 recalls, 1 crash risk 4th worst of 25 Highlander years

Top 2019 Toyota Highlander problems

1

Transmission whine, rough shifting, and sudden power loss

217 complaints · usually at 15,000–93,000 miles
What to look forHide

Owners often describe a whining sound from the transmission area that gets louder when they press the accelerator, followed by hard, jerky, or erratic shifts. Some also report hesitation or weak acceleration from a stop, getting stuck in one gear, or a sudden loss of power, sometimes with no warning light. These problems have been reported at mileages from about 51,000 to 110,000, and dealers frequently recommend replacing the transmission, which owners say can be costly and hard to source.

Signs to watch for

  • Whining noise that grows louder when accelerating
  • Hard, jerky, or delayed shifts between gears
  • Hesitation or weak acceleration from a stop
  • Stuck in one gear or unexpected downshifts
  • Sudden loss of power with no warning light
All 2019 Toyota Highlander transmission problems → Highlander transmission problems in every year →
2

Fuel pump recall: stalling and hesitation while driving

109 complaints · usually at 4,000–16,000 miles
What to look forHide

Owners of the 2019 Highlander describe a delay when pressing the accelerator, especially from a stop or at low speed in traffic, followed by a loss of power. Many say the engine can stall without warning, sometimes at highway speed, and in some cases will not restart. Many of these reports are tied to a low-pressure fuel pump recall, and some owners say the repair parts were not yet available.

Signs to watch for

  • Hesitation when pressing the gas from a stop
  • Sudden loss of power or stalling while driving
  • Jerking or lurching during acceleration
  • Check engine and traction control warning lights
  • Engine will not restart after stalling

Related recalls: 20V682000, 20V012000

All 2019 Toyota Highlander fuel system problems →
3

Sudden stalling and power loss while driving

77 complaints · usually at 5,000–33,000 miles
What to look forHide

Owners of the 2019 Highlander describe the engine losing power or cutting out, often at low speeds in traffic, at stop lights, or while pulling away from a stop. Many say warning lights such as check engine, hybrid system, or pre-collision messages appear just before or during the problem. Some traced it to a fuel delivery issue, while many dealers could not reproduce the fault, and the car sometimes would not restart afterward.

Signs to watch for

  • Engine loses power while driving
  • Hesitation or lag when pressing the accelerator
  • Stalls at stop lights or in slow traffic
  • Hybrid system or check engine warning lights
  • Car won't restart after shutting down
Highlander engine problems in every year →
4

Electrical problems

56 complaints · usually at 2,000–25,000 miles
What to look forHide

56 complaints (11%) name the electrical system.

Highlander electrical system problems in every year →

Symptoms 2019 Toyota Highlander owners describe

How many complaints mention each symptom in the owner's own words. One complaint can mention several.

Stalling while driving 61
Check engine light on 48
Sudden loss of power 35
Jerking when accelerating 23
Hesitation when accelerating 21

Which parts fail most

Share of complaints that name each system. One complaint can name several.

Unknown or Other 16%
Engine 15%
Electrical 11%
Brakes 4%
Airbags 3%
Acceleration 3%
Body 2%
Emergency Braking 2%

Mileage when it failed

Each dot is a complaint that gave a mileage (142 of 517). The amber line is the middle value, about 13,000 miles.

When problems were reported

Complaints by the year the problem happened.

2019 Toyota Highlander recalls

Fuel pump may fail and stall engine

Can stall

The low-pressure fuel pump inside the fuel tank may fail. If it does, the engine can stall while you are driving, which raises the risk of a crash.

Fix: A Toyota dealer will replace the fuel pump assembly with an improved one at no cost to you.

Recall 20V682000 · Nov 2020

Fuel pump may fail and stall engine

Can stall

The low-pressure fuel pump inside the fuel tank can fail, which can cause the engine to stall while you are driving. A sudden stall raises the risk of a crash.

Fix: Dealers will replace the fuel pump free of charge, and Toyota will notify affected owners.

Recall 20V012000 · Jan 2020

Tire load label may become unreadable

Crash risk

The load capacity label on the vehicle may fade until it cannot be read. Without it, the driver may not know the vehicle is overloaded, which raises the risk of a crash.

Fix: The dealer will install a corrected load carrying capacity label at no charge.

Recall 19V244000 · Mar 2019
Check your VIN for open recalls

All Toyota Highlander recalls, every year →

Get an email when your car gets a new recall

We check NHTSA every day. If a new recall or safety investigation covers your car, you'll hear about it the same week.

Your car

One email per new recall for the car you pick. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Highlander years to avoid

Total NHTSA complaints by model year. Newer years have had less time on the road, so their totals will keep climbing. See the full comparison.

2019 Toyota Highlander problems by system

Common questions

Is the 2019 Toyota Highlander a reliable year?

It's one of the worst years for the Highlander. Owners have filed 517 complaints with NHTSA, the 4th most of 25 Highlander model years. The most reported problems involve the transmission, fuel system and engine. Transmission complaints most often came at about 15,000–93,000 miles.

Are there any issues with the 2019 Toyota Highlander?

Yes. Owners have filed 517 complaints with NHTSA, most often about the transmission, fuel system and engine, and there are 3 recalls. The symptoms owners mention most are whining noise, stalling while driving and check engine light on.

What are the most common 2019 Toyota Highlander problems?

Owners most often report problems with the transmission, fuel system, engine and electrical system. Owners often describe a whining sound from the transmission area that gets louder when they press the accelerator, followed by hard, jerky, or erratic shifts. Some also report hesitation or weak acceleration from a stop, getting stuck in one gear, or a sudden loss of power, sometimes with no warning light. These problems have been reported at mileages from about 51,000 to 110,000, and dealers frequently recommend replacing the transmission, which owners say can be costly and hard to source.

Does the 2019 Toyota Highlander have transmission issues?

Yes, it's the most reported problem area for the 2019 Toyota Highlander: 217 owners (42% of complaints) have reported transmission issues to NHTSA, most often at about 15,000–93,000 miles.

At what mileage do 2019 Toyota Highlander transmission problems start?

Reported mileage ranged widely, but most complaints fell between about 15,000–93,000 miles, with a middle value near 68,000 miles.

How many recalls does the 2019 Toyota Highlander have?

3. Fuel pump may fail and stall engine (20V682000); Fuel pump may fail and stall engine (20V012000); Tire load label may become unreadable (19V244000). Check your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls to see if the work was done.

Should I buy a used 2019 Toyota Highlander?

Ask for service records covering the transmission, confirm the recall work was done, and compare with the 2025, 2024 and 2016 models, which have the fewest complaints.

Source: NHTSA complaints and recalls databases. Complaints are unverified owner reports, summarized in our own words. Counts include each complaint once per model year.

Terms & Conditions

Car Years to Avoid summarizes public NHTSA owner complaint and recall data for general information only. Complaints are unverified owner reports, so treat them as a guide, not a verdict on any specific vehicle.

Nothing here is mechanical, legal or buying advice. Always check a VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls and get a pre-purchase inspection. We may earn from ads and partner links. Not affiliated with NHTSA or any automaker.

Privacy

If you sign up for recall alerts, we store your email and the car you picked, and use them only to send those alerts. We never sell your email, and you can unsubscribe anytime from any alert.

Like most sites, we use cookies and analytics tools (Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity) to understand how people use the site and keep it free.