2009 Toyota Highlander Problems
What owners have reported about the 2009 Toyota Highlander: which problems and issues come up most, at what mileage, and which recalls to check.
From NHTSA owner complaints and recalls. Updated Nov 16, 2026.
Is the 2009 Toyota Highlander a good year?
It's one of the better years for the Highlander. Owners have filed 174 complaints with NHTSA, the 20th most of 25 Highlander model years. The most reported problems involve the brakes, engine and electrical system. Brakes complaints most often came at about 10,000–147,000 miles.
174 complaints 10 recalls, 3 fire risk 20th worst of 25 Highlander years
Top 2009 Toyota Highlander problems
1 Brake pauses and ABS actuator warning lights
What to look forHide
Owners describe two related patterns. Some notice a brief pause, fade, or surge when braking, often on slick or rough roads, on downhill grades, or during firm pedal presses, usually lasting under a second. Others see ABS and brake warning lights come on, sometimes with croaking or clicking sounds, and dealers often point to the brake actuator as the cause.
Signs to watch for
- Brief pause before the brakes respond
- Sudden release of pressure, then the brakes come back
- ABS, brake, or traction warning lights on the dash
- Croaking or clicking noise when braking
- Longer stopping distance with the ABS light on
2 Oil cooler line leaks causing sudden oil loss
What to look forHide
Owners of the 2009 Highlander, including some with the towing package, often report that the rubber oil cooler line or hose cracked or burst while they were driving. The leak can drain engine oil quickly, and some owners describe power loss, overheating, engine damage, or a fire. Several say repairs were limited or not covered because Toyota handled the issue through a service bulletin rather than a recall.
Signs to watch for
- Low oil pressure warning while driving
- Oil dripping or pooling under the front of the car
- Sudden loss of power or stalling
- Grinding or knocking noise from the engine
- Smoke rising from under the hood
3 Power liftgate and door lock electrical failures
What to look forHide
Owners report that the power liftgate often refuses to open or close, can stall partway, or may open on its own, and that the power door lock actuators keep failing or show the wrong lock status. Some also describe dead batteries, flickering dashboard lights, climate controls acting erratically, and in a few cases sudden power loss with hybrid warnings. These problems tend to build up over time and sometimes come back after repairs.
Signs to watch for
- Liftgate won't open or close with the button
- Liftgate stalls partway or opens by itself
- Door locks fail or show the wrong lock status
- Dead battery or repeated starting trouble
- Dashboard lights flicker or climate controls act erratically
4 Unintended acceleration and failure to slow
What to look forHide
Owners describe the vehicle speeding up on its own, sometimes at low speed while parking, reversing, or pulling away from a stop, and sometimes at highway speed. Several report that pressing the brake did little to slow the car, and a floor mat catching the pedal was mentioned in some cases. Dealers frequently could not reproduce the problem, and many vehicles were returned without a confirmed repair.
Signs to watch for
- Car speeds up without the driver pressing the gas
- Accelerator feels stuck or slow to release
- Brakes do not slow the car while it accelerates
- Lurching forward when moving from a stop or reversing
- Floor mat catching under the accelerator pedal
Which parts fail most
Share of complaints that name each system. One complaint can name several.
Mileage when it failed
Each dot is a complaint that gave a mileage (139 of 174). The amber line is the middle value, about 60,000 miles.
When problems were reported
Complaints by the year the problem happened.
2009 Toyota Highlander recalls
Damaged seat heater wiring can cause fire
Fire risk
The wiring in the seat heaters can be damaged when the seat cushion is compressed. If it is damaged, the copper heating element may short circuit and increase the risk of a fire.
Fix: The dealer will disconnect the seat heaters free of charge and refund the purchase price of the seat heater accessory.
Recall 16V396000 · Jun 2016Window switch may overheat and cause fire
Fire risk
Grease may have been unevenly applied inside the power window master switch, leaving its electrical contacts unprotected. Moisture or debris can then short the switch, causing it to overheat, melt, and raise the risk of a fire.
Fix: The dealer will inspect the switch, add lubricant if it is fine, or replace the circuit board if a problem is found, and the repair is free of charge.
Recall 15V689000 · Oct 2015Seat heater wiring can short and burn
Fire risk
Pressure on the seat cushion can damage the seat heater wiring, and the damaged wires can short out. This can cause the seat to burn and injure the person sitting in it.
Fix: A dealer will disconnect the affected seat heaters and refund the purchase price of the seat heater accessory, free of charge.
Recall 14V743000 · Nov 2014Driver airbag may fail to deploy
Injury risk
The wiring to the driver's airbag can be damaged when the steering wheel is turned, because a flat cable is pinched or worn by its retainer. If that happens, the airbag can be turned off and would not inflate in a crash that needs it, raising the risk of injury to the driver.
Fix: Toyota will notify owners and send a second letter when remedy parts are available; the dealer then repairs the steering column spiral cable assembly, and the remedy is free of charge.
Recall 14V168000 · Apr 2014Inverter module may cause sudden hybrid shutdown
Can stall
The power module inside the inverter can overheat because its solder cannot handle the heat, which can damage its transistors. When this happens, warning lights come on, and the car may enter limp-home mode or shut off its hybrid system while driving, causing an unexpected stall and a higher risk of crash.
Fix: Your Toyota dealer will replace the intelligent power module free of charge, though cars that already had it replaced under recall 11V-342 are not included.
Recall 13V396000 · Sep 2013Passenger airbag may not deploy correctly
Injury risk
Dealer-installed accessories such as leather seat covers, seat heaters, or headrest DVD systems may have skipped a required test of the passenger seat sensor. If that sensor is out of calibration, the passenger airbag may not deploy or may deploy wrongly for the passenger's size and seat position, raising the risk of injury in a crash.
Fix: The dealer will test the passenger occupant sensors and recalibrate them as needed, but the recall notice does not say whether this is free, so confirm the cost with the dealer.
Recall 13V014000 · Jan 2013Missing tire and load capacity labels
Crash risk
These vehicles were sold without the required labels showing tire selection and load-carrying capacity. Without that information, a driver may overload the vehicle, which can raise the risk of a crash.
Fix: The dealer will mail you the corrected label, or you can ask the dealer to install it for free.
Recall 10V036000 · Feb 2010Missing tire load capacity labels
Some vehicles sold between September 2005 and June 2008 did not have the required tire load-carrying capacity labels. This does not meet federal standards, and without the label owners may not have the correct tire load information.
Fix: The dealer will mail you a corrected label, or you can have the dealer install it for free, and the dealer will also correct your owner's manual.
Recall 10V035000 · Feb 2010Floor mat can trap accelerator pedal open
Crash risk
A driver's floor mat that is loose or the wrong type can trap the gas pedal in the fully open position, causing the car to speed up and making it hard to stop. This can lead to a crash, serious injury, or death.
Fix: The dealer will modify or replace the accelerator pedals, and the recall notice does not say whether this is free.
Recall 10V023000 · Jan 2010Missing or incorrect load capacity label
Crash risk
Some vehicles lack a correct load capacity label, which fails federal tire and rim standard FMVSS 110. Without accurate information, the vehicle could be overloaded, increasing the risk of a crash.
Fix: Toyota will notify you and provide a new, accurate label to install over the incorrect one, free of charge.
Recall 09V223000 · Jun 2009Get an email when your car gets a new recall
We check NHTSA every day. If a new recall or safety investigation covers your car, you'll hear about it the same week.
One email per new recall for the car you pick. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Highlander years to avoid
Total NHTSA complaints by model year. Newer years have had less time on the road, so their totals will keep climbing. See the full comparison.
Common questions
Is the 2009 Toyota Highlander a reliable year?
It's one of the better years for the Highlander. Owners have filed 174 complaints with NHTSA, the 20th most of 25 Highlander model years. The most reported problems involve the brakes, engine and electrical system. Brakes complaints most often came at about 10,000–147,000 miles.
Are there any issues with the 2009 Toyota Highlander?
Yes. Owners have filed 174 complaints with NHTSA, most often about the brakes, engine and electrical system, and there are 10 recalls.
What are the most common 2009 Toyota Highlander problems?
Owners most often report problems with the brakes, engine, electrical system and acceleration and speed control. Owners describe two related patterns. Some notice a brief pause, fade, or surge when braking, often on slick or rough roads, on downhill grades, or during firm pedal presses, usually lasting under a second. Others see ABS and brake warning lights come on, sometimes with croaking or clicking sounds, and dealers often point to the brake actuator as the cause.
Does the 2009 Toyota Highlander have brakes issues?
Yes, it's the most reported problem area for the 2009 Toyota Highlander: 55 owners (32% of complaints) have reported brakes issues to NHTSA, most often at about 10,000–147,000 miles.
At what mileage do 2009 Toyota Highlander brakes problems start?
Reported mileage ranged widely, but most complaints fell between about 10,000–147,000 miles, with a middle value near 86,000 miles.
How many recalls does the 2009 Toyota Highlander have?
10. Damaged seat heater wiring can cause fire (16V396000); Window switch may overheat and cause fire (15V689000); Seat heater wiring can short and burn (14V743000). Check your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls to see if the work was done.
Should I buy a used 2009 Toyota Highlander?
Ask for service records covering the brakes, confirm the recall work was done, and compare with the 2025, 2024 and 2016 models, which have the fewest complaints.
Source: NHTSA complaints and recalls databases. Complaints are unverified owner reports, summarized in our own words. Counts include each complaint once per model year.