How We Count Complaints
Where the data comes from, how each number on the site is worked out, and its limits.
Data last updated Nov 16, 2026.
Where the data comes from
Everything comes from the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the federal agency that tracks vehicle safety. We use two of its public databases:
- Owner complaints: reports that drivers file with NHTSA about a safety problem with their vehicle. Each one names the vehicle, the system involved (like the transmission or airbags), often the mileage, and the owner's description of what happened.
- Recalls: every safety recall campaign, with the defect, the risk and the fix.
We download NHTSA's full files and rebuild the whole site from them every day, so new complaints and recalls show up soon after NHTSA publishes them. We cover model years 2000 and newer.
What a complaint is, and isn't
Complaints are unverified. NHTSA doesn't confirm each one, and owners describe problems in their own words. A complaint tells you what an owner experienced, not that a defect has been proven. That's why we show counts and patterns across many owners, never a single story as fact.
Complaints also aren't a full reliability survey. Owners mostly report safety-related problems, and only some owners who have a problem file a report. Popular models draw more complaints simply because more of them are on the road, so we use the numbers mainly to compare years of the same model.
How we count
- One complaint, counted once per model year. A complaint that names several systems counts once in the year total and once under each system it names.
- Problem areas use NHTSA's own system categories, grouped into reader-friendly names (for example "Power train" becomes Transmission).
- Mileage is the mileage owners gave when the problem happened. We show the middle value and the range that covers the middle half of reports, and ignore obviously wrong values.
- Symptoms (like "jerking when accelerating") are found by matching phrases in the owner's own description, so one complaint can count toward several symptoms.
- Pages exist for model years with at least 25 complaints, and for problem areas and symptoms with enough complaints to say something useful. Thinner data stays on the parent page.
How years are ranked
The "worst years" are the model years with the most complaints in total.
Totals favor older cars, which have had more time to collect reports. So when we name the best years, we use complaints per year on the road: a model year's complaints divided by the number of years since it went on sale. We only call a year one of the best once it has at least three years of owner reports, so brand-new years don't look good just because nobody has complained yet.
A model year's verdict ("one of the worst years", "about average", "one of the better years") puts it in the worst, middle or best third of that model's years by complaint count.
Summaries in plain English
The short problem and recall summaries are written with the help of an AI model. It reads a sample of complaints, or NHTSA's recall notice, and rewrites them in plain English. It isn't allowed to add numbers that aren't in the source. Every count, chart and ranking comes straight from NHTSA's data, not from the summaries. Owner details like names, VINs and locations are never shown.
Independence
Car Years to Avoid isn't affiliated with NHTSA, any automaker or any dealer. The site is supported by ads and partner offers, which never affect the data or rankings.
Found an error? Email partners@forsomeonewho.com. See also about us.