2016 Toyota Highlander Problems
What owners have reported about the 2016 Toyota Highlander: which problems and issues come up most, at what mileage, and which recalls to check.
From NHTSA owner complaints and recalls. Updated Nov 16, 2026.
Is the 2016 Toyota Highlander a good year?
It's one of the better years for the Highlander. Owners have filed 117 complaints with NHTSA, the 23rd most of 25 Highlander model years. The most reported problems involve the brakes, electrical system and airbags. Brakes complaints most often came at about 20,000–42,000 miles.
117 complaints 3 recalls, 2 crash risk 23rd worst of 25 Highlander years
Top 2016 Toyota Highlander problems
1 Brake failure, pedal loss, and unexpected braking reports
What to look forHide
Owners describe brakes that do not slow the car as expected, including soft pedals that sink toward the floor and cases where the vehicle keeps moving or seems to speed up. Some report sudden braking with no driver input, along with vibration when braking at highway speeds and warning lights that come and go. Many of these reports involve low-speed driving in parking lots, backing out, rolling on slopes, or stopping at intersections, and several owners say dealers could not find a fault.
Signs to watch for
- Brake pedal feels spongy or sinks toward the floor
- Car keeps moving or does not slow when brakes are applied
- Sudden braking with no input from the driver
- Shudder or vibration when braking at higher speeds
- Brake or ABS warning lights that come on and go off
2 Electrical glitches: unexpected starts, stalls, and random alerts
What to look forHide
Owners of the 2016 Highlander describe a wide range of electrical faults. Some say the engine started or kept running while the car was parked, and others report the engine cutting out while driving, with displays flickering or going dark. Several also mention features like parking sensors, rain wipers, and phone connectivity acting on their own, along with a fuel pump that keeps running long after shutdown and battery or wiring problems.
Signs to watch for
- Engine starts or runs while parked
- Engine cuts out while driving
- Dashboard displays flicker or go dark
- Parking sensors or wipers activate randomly
- Fuel pump runs long after shutdown
3 Airbags reportedly fail to deploy in serious crashes
What to look forHide
Owners describe airbags that stayed silent in crashes that seemed severe enough to trigger them, including rollovers, rear-end collisions, and vehicles leaving the road. Several reports say the driver or passenger struck the steering wheel or door pillar with no airbag firing, and some mention a warning light that would not reset or a Takata recall. These problems surface only after a crash, when the airbags are needed most.
Signs to watch for
- No airbag deployment during a significant crash
- Head striking the steering wheel or pillar with no airbag firing
- Airbag warning light stays on or will not reset
- Side or curtain airbags reported as not working after impact
4 Engine problems
What to look forHide
10 complaints (9%) name the engine.
Highlander engine problems in every year →Which parts fail most
Share of complaints that name each system. One complaint can name several.
Mileage when it failed
Each dot is a complaint that gave a mileage (73 of 117). The amber line is the middle value, about 28,000 miles.
When problems were reported
Complaints by the year the problem happened.
2016 Toyota Highlander recalls
Windshield wire leak can stall engine
Can stall
Water can leak into a wire harness attached to the windshield and damage the engine control module, the computer that runs the engine. That damage can make the engine stall, which increases the risk of a crash.
Fix: A dealer will replace the windshield, inspect the engine control module for damage, and replace the module if needed, all free of charge.
Recall 18E107000 · Nov 2018Brake fluid sensor may not detect low fluid
Crash risk
The brake fluid level sensor may not be connected to its wiring, so low brake fluid could go unnoticed. Reduced braking performance could increase the risk of a crash.
Fix: A dealer will inspect the sensor wiring and connect it if needed, free of charge.
Recall 16V775000 · Oct 2016Incorrect load label may lead to overloading
Crash risk
The label showing how much weight your vehicle can carry may list the wrong added weight for installed accessories, so the vehicle does not fully meet federal tire and rim safety rules. Believing the label is correct could lead you to overload the vehicle, which raises the risk of a crash.
Fix: SET will notify you and provide a corrected label to place over the inaccurate one, free of charge.
Recall 16V420000 · Jun 2016Get an email when your car gets a new recall
We check NHTSA every day. If a new recall or safety investigation covers your car, you'll hear about it the same week.
One email per new recall for the car you pick. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Highlander years to avoid
Total NHTSA complaints by model year. Newer years have had less time on the road, so their totals will keep climbing. See the full comparison.
Common questions
Is the 2016 Toyota Highlander a reliable year?
It's one of the better years for the Highlander. Owners have filed 117 complaints with NHTSA, the 23rd most of 25 Highlander model years. The most reported problems involve the brakes, electrical system and airbags. Brakes complaints most often came at about 20,000–42,000 miles.
Are there any issues with the 2016 Toyota Highlander?
Yes. Owners have filed 117 complaints with NHTSA, most often about the brakes, electrical system and airbags, and there are 3 recalls.
What are the most common 2016 Toyota Highlander problems?
Owners most often report problems with the brakes, electrical system, airbags and engine. Owners describe brakes that do not slow the car as expected, including soft pedals that sink toward the floor and cases where the vehicle keeps moving or seems to speed up. Some report sudden braking with no driver input, along with vibration when braking at highway speeds and warning lights that come and go. Many of these reports involve low-speed driving in parking lots, backing out, rolling on slopes, or stopping at intersections, and several owners say dealers could not find a fault.
Does the 2016 Toyota Highlander have brakes issues?
Yes, it's the most reported problem area for the 2016 Toyota Highlander: 22 owners (19% of complaints) have reported brakes issues to NHTSA, most often at about 20,000–42,000 miles.
At what mileage do 2016 Toyota Highlander brakes problems start?
Reported mileage ranged widely, but most complaints fell between about 20,000–42,000 miles, with a middle value near 28,000 miles.
How many recalls does the 2016 Toyota Highlander have?
3. Windshield wire leak can stall engine (18E107000); Brake fluid sensor may not detect low fluid (16V775000); Incorrect load label may lead to overloading (16V420000). Check your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls to see if the work was done.
Should I buy a used 2016 Toyota Highlander?
Ask for service records covering the brakes, confirm the recall work was done, and compare with the 2025, 2024 and 2016 models, which have the fewest complaints.
Source: NHTSA complaints and recalls databases. Complaints are unverified owner reports, summarized in our own words. Counts include each complaint once per model year.