Car Yearsto Avoid

2019 Subaru Forester Engine Problems

From NHTSA owner complaints and recalls. Updated Nov 16, 2026.

Does the 2019 Subaru Forester have engine issues?

Yes, it's one of the more common complaints for the 2019 Subaru Forester. 111 owners have reported engine problems to NHTSA, 13% of all complaints for this year (the 3rd most reported problem area). Most reported problems happened at about 10,000–67,000 miles. 1 recall covers this area.

111 complaints 13% of all 2019 complaints 30,000 miles typical

What owners report

Failing thermal control valve disables safety systems

Owners report that a failed thermal control valve often turns on the check engine light and shuts off EyeSight and other driver-assist features. Some also lose heat and defroster function, which can leave windows fogged in cold or wet weather. Reports describe this happening at many different mileages and ages, sometimes while driving at highway speed, and some owners say parts were hard to get or the repair wasn't covered.

  • Check engine light with a cold-engine warning
  • EyeSight and driver-assist features switch off
  • Heater or defroster stops working and windows fog up
  • Engine stalls, loses power, or runs too hot
  • Multiple dashboard warning lights come on at once

Did Subaru fix the Forester engine problems?

Mostly, in later years. Later Forester years draw far fewer engine complaints: about 7 complaints per year on the road for the 2020, 2021 and 2022, against 14 for the 2019. Owners are still reporting it: 11 complaints describe problems that happened in 2025 or 2026.

Subaru Forester engine problems in every year →

Mileage when it failed

Each dot is a complaint that gave a mileage (23 of 111). The amber line is the middle value.

When problems were reported

Engine complaints by the year the problem happened.

Engine complaints by Forester year

2019 Forester 111
2020 Forester 85
2014 Forester 72
2011 Forester 67
2016 Forester 60
2017 Forester 48
2010 Forester 40
2004 Forester 39
2009 Forester 39
See more (17)See less
2021 Forester 36
2018 Forester 32
2003 Forester 31
2012 Forester 29
2013 Forester 27
2006 Forester 22
2001 Forester 18
2002 Forester 15
2007 Forester 15
2000 Forester 12
2022 Forester 11
2005 Forester 10
2008 Forester 9
2023 Forester 6
2025 Forester 4
2024 Forester 1
2026 Forester 1

Related recalls

PCV valve may separate, causing power loss

Crash risk

The aluminum PCV valve, which vents gases from the engine's crankcase, can break apart and let pieces enter the engine. This can cause a sudden loss of power while driving, which raises the risk of a crash.

Fix: Your Subaru dealer will inspect and replace the PCV valve free of charge, and if the broken parts cannot be found, they will replace the short block engine at no cost.

Recall 19V856000 · Dec 2019
Check your VIN for open recalls

Get an email when your car gets a new recall

We check NHTSA every day. If a new recall or safety investigation covers your car, you'll hear about it the same week.

Your car

One email per new recall for the car you pick. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Other 2019 Subaru Forester problems

Common questions

Does the 2019 Subaru Forester have engine issues?

Yes, it's one of the more common complaints for the 2019 Subaru Forester. 111 owners have reported engine problems to NHTSA, 13% of all complaints for this year (the 3rd most reported problem area). Most reported problems happened at about 10,000–67,000 miles. 1 recall covers this area.

Did Subaru fix the Forester engine problems?

Mostly. Later Forester years draw far fewer engine complaints: about 7 complaints per year on the road for the 2020, 2021 and 2022, against 14 for the 2019. Owners are still reporting it: 11 complaints describe problems that happened in 2025 or 2026.

What are common 2019 Subaru Forester engine problems?

Owners report that a failed thermal control valve often turns on the check engine light and shuts off EyeSight and other driver-assist features. Some also lose heat and defroster function, which can leave windows fogged in cold or wet weather. Reports describe this happening at many different mileages and ages, sometimes while driving at highway speed, and some owners say parts were hard to get or the repair wasn't covered.

At what mileage do 2019 Subaru Forester engine problems happen?

Most complaints that gave a mileage fell between about 10,000–67,000 miles. The middle value is about 30,000 miles.

Is there a recall for 2019 Subaru Forester engine problems?

Yes: 19V856000. Check your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls to see if the work was done.

Which Forester year has the most engine complaints?

The 2015 Forester, with 136 complaints.

Source: NHTSA complaints and recalls databases. Complaints are unverified owner reports, summarized in our own words.

Terms & Conditions

Car Years to Avoid summarizes public NHTSA owner complaint and recall data for general information only. Complaints are unverified owner reports, so treat them as a guide, not a verdict on any specific vehicle.

Nothing here is mechanical, legal or buying advice. Always check a VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls and get a pre-purchase inspection. We may earn from ads and partner links. Not affiliated with NHTSA or any automaker.

Privacy

If you sign up for recall alerts, we store your email and the car you picked, and use them only to send those alerts. We never sell your email, and you can unsubscribe anytime from any alert.

Like most sites, we use cookies and analytics tools (Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity) to understand how people use the site and keep it free.