2005 Subaru Forester Problems
What owners have reported about the 2005 Subaru Forester: which problems and issues come up most, at what mileage, and which recalls to check.
From NHTSA owner complaints and recalls. Updated Nov 16, 2026.
Is the 2005 Subaru Forester a good year?
It's about average for this model. Owners have filed 93 complaints with NHTSA, the 18th most of 27 Forester model years. The most reported problems involve the fuel system, suspension and acceleration and speed control. Fuel system complaints most often came at about 50,000–153,000 miles.
93 complaints 1 recall, 1 crash risk 18th worst of 27 Forester years
Top 2005 Subaru Forester problems
1 Cold-weather fuel smell and leaks from rubber lines
What to look forHide
Owners report a strong raw gasoline odor inside and outside the cabin when outside temperatures fall to roughly 20 to 30°F, especially on cold starts and with the heater running. Many traced the leak to rubber fuel hoses under the intake manifold, where the clamps seem to lose their grip as the cold stiffens and shrinks the hose. The smell often fades once the engine reaches normal operating temperature.
Signs to watch for
- Strong gasoline smell in the cabin when the heat is on
- Raw fuel odor outside the car during cold starts
- Fuel dripping or pooling under the intake manifold
- Damp or leaking rubber fuel hose near the engine
- Smell fading after the engine warms up
2 Rusted front lower control arms can fracture
What to look forHide
Owners report that the front lower control arms, especially on the passenger side, rust through at the welds or brackets over time. Some say the 2011 recall inspection and rustproofing did not stop the damage, and the arms failed again later. Reported failures include sudden loss of steering control, a wheel tucking into the fender, and crashes, sometimes with no warning light.
Signs to watch for
- Loud bang or clunk from the front end
- Steering feels loose, unresponsive, or suddenly locked
- Front wheel leaning inward or hanging out of the wheel well
- Pulling or drifting to one side while driving
- Vibration or shaking at highway speed
3 Unintended acceleration at low speeds and while braking
What to look forHide
Owners of the 2005 Subaru Forester describe the car surging forward without warning, often while pulling into a space, backing out, or stopping at a light with the brake applied. Some say the throttle ignored their input and the car only crept along at idle, while others say it kept speeding up after they released the pedal or used the cruise coast control. Many report that dealers found no fault during testing, though a few mention a throttle sensor code that could not be reproduced.
Signs to watch for
- Car lurches forward when the pedal is lightly touched
- Brakes struggle to hold the car back
- Engine revs climb even with foot off the gas
- Throttle does not respond and car only creeps at idle
- Speed keeps rising after cruise coast is used
4 Misfires, stalls, head gasket and catalytic converter failures
What to look forHide
Owners describe a range of engine problems on the 2005 Forester, including hesitation and misfiring, stalling with the check engine light on, and catalytic converters that needed repeated replacement. Some report head gasket leaks or cracked cylinder heads, while others mention oil loss, fuel fumes from a leaking line, or sudden unintended acceleration. Many say the symptoms showed up in cold or wet weather or returned after dealer visits, though experiences vary.
Signs to watch for
- Hesitation, sputtering or bucking in wet weather
- Stalling with the check engine light on
- Rough running or harsh downshifts with knocking noises
- Oil level dropping between oil changes
- Strong fuel odor inside the cabin in cold weather
Symptoms 2005 Subaru Forester owners describe
How many complaints mention each symptom in the owner's own words. One complaint can mention several.
Which parts fail most
Share of complaints that name each system. One complaint can name several.
Mileage when it failed
Each dot is a complaint that gave a mileage (78 of 93). The amber line is the middle value, about 80,000 miles.
When problems were reported
Complaints by the year the problem happened.
2005 Subaru Forester recalls
Front control arms may corrode and break
Crash risk
Road salt and moisture can corrode the hanger brackets on the front lower control arms until they break. A broken control arm can cause loss of vehicle control and raise the risk of a crash.
Fix: The dealer will inspect the front lower control arms for corrosion and either rustproof or replace them, though the notice does not say whether this is free.
Recall 11V464000 · Sep 2011Get an email when your car gets a new recall
We check NHTSA every day. If a new recall or safety investigation covers your car, you'll hear about it the same week.
One email per new recall for the car you pick. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Forester years to avoid
Total NHTSA complaints by model year. Newer years have had less time on the road, so their totals will keep climbing. See the full comparison.
Common questions
Is the 2005 Subaru Forester a reliable year?
It's about average for this model. Owners have filed 93 complaints with NHTSA, the 18th most of 27 Forester model years. The most reported problems involve the fuel system, suspension and acceleration and speed control. Fuel system complaints most often came at about 50,000–153,000 miles.
Are there any issues with the 2005 Subaru Forester?
Yes. Owners have filed 93 complaints with NHTSA, most often about the fuel system, suspension and acceleration and speed control, and there is 1 recall. The symptoms owners mention most are fuel smell or leak.
What are the most common 2005 Subaru Forester problems?
Owners most often report problems with the fuel system, suspension, acceleration and speed control and engine. Owners report a strong raw gasoline odor inside and outside the cabin when outside temperatures fall to roughly 20 to 30°F, especially on cold starts and with the heater running. Many traced the leak to rubber fuel hoses under the intake manifold, where the clamps seem to lose their grip as the cold stiffens and shrinks the hose. The smell often fades once the engine reaches normal operating temperature.
Does the 2005 Subaru Forester have fuel system issues?
Yes, it's the most reported problem area for the 2005 Subaru Forester: 22 owners (24% of complaints) have reported fuel system issues to NHTSA, most often at about 50,000–153,000 miles.
At what mileage do 2005 Subaru Forester fuel system problems start?
Reported mileage ranged widely, but most complaints fell between about 50,000–153,000 miles, with a middle value near 93,000 miles.
How many recalls does the 2005 Subaru Forester have?
1. Front control arms may corrode and break (11V464000). Check your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls to see if the work was done.
Should I buy a used 2005 Subaru Forester?
Ask for service records covering the fuel system, confirm the recall work was done, and compare with the 2024, 2026 and 2008 models, which have the fewest complaints.
Source: NHTSA complaints and recalls databases. Complaints are unverified owner reports, summarized in our own words. Counts include each complaint once per model year.